The right baby crib mattress will get you off to a good start as a new parent. Since there are a few things in a baby’s life that will compete with their sleep time, they'll need a comfortable mattress with a good level of support. Infants are safer on a firmer crib mattress, but you can slowly transition to a plush one once they are older and able to move around. Find your baby the very best crib mattress on our list of favorites.
Graco premium foam mattress
A breathable foam mattress for proper air flow
Unlike the memory foam used in adult mattresses, this one uses a polyurethane foam, which is absolutely comfortable and safe for babies. This baby crib mattress comes with a convenient removable outer cover that is water-resistant and washable. The core is made of breathable foam, which maximizes airflow, and it is firm enough for infant safety and development. Measuring 52-by-27.6-by-five inches, it is designed to fit most standard full-size cribs and toddler beds.
Milliard Crib Mattress Flip Technology
For a peaceful baby to toddler transition
While newborns require a firmer mattress, they'll need a comfy and form-fitting surface as they grow older. We love that the double-sided Milliard crib mattress is built with flip technology for a peaceful transition. One side is firmer with a pure foam base and a supportive layer for infants or newborns, while the other side is made of memory foam to offer a softer, body-contouring sleeping surface. The mattress is then encased in a soft bamboo cover that is water-resistant and washable. It is lead, mercury, or VOC-free and measures 52-by-27.5-by-5.5 inches, a standard for typical cribs and toddler beds.
Dream On Me extra firm fiber portable crib mattress
The perfect mix of support and comfort
Measuring 38-by-24-by-3 inches, this firm crib mattresses fits snugly into most mini cribs and portable options. The mattress is constructed with excellent craftmanship using a fiber core that creates a firm foundation and excellent support for your baby's early days. It comes with a durable vinyl cover that is waterproof, hypoallergenic, and antibacterial to prevent mold and odor from seeping into the mattress. To clean the cover, simply use soap and water.
Dream On Me orthopedic firm foam crib mattress
Comfort and safety redefined
This is an orthopedic foam mattress designed for baby cribs. The mattress comes with a hypoallergenic cover that is also water-resistant and has antibacterial properties. These properties ensure that the mattress is safe for your child. The cover is easy to clean with warm water and mild soap. The construction does not use phthalates or lead-based materials. Your child will be sleeping on a vented mattress that discourages odor and mildew.
My First Mattress crib mattress
A safe sleeping haven for your baby
My First Mattress is a CertiPur-US certified memory foam mattress that is so comfortable for your baby even as he/she grows. This premium firm crib mattress provides a comfortable and safe surface for a restful night's sleep. It has a soft velour crib mattress cover that is removable, waterproof, and washable. Since it's hypoallergenic, mite-proof, and lead and phthalate-free, it offers the safest sleeping environment for your baby.
Safe and comfortable sleep for babies
Why you can trust Real Homes Our expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing products and services so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about how we test.
Babies thrive in comfort and because they spend most of their time sleeping, choosing a safe and comfortable baby crib mattress is paramount.
We love the Graco premium foam mattress because it meets all the comfort and safety needs of a baby's first months. Besides being a perfect fit for most standard US cribs, it only requires about 48 to 72 hours to completely decompress.
For more versatility, nothing beats Milliard's crib mattress with Flip Technology. This mattress has a firmer side for infants and a memory foam side for older babies and toddlers.