Peanut butter is food that is high in protein and can be added to many different dishes. Maybe you like it on bread with jelly, or you like to dip your veggies into it. However you enjoy eating it, there are lots of savory options out there. We've gathered a collection of our favorite peanut butter options to help you narrow down your choices.
SKIPPY creamy peanut butter
Small and large jar options
Skippy works great in many recipes, from entrees to desserts.
Pros:
- Does not separate
- Can be heated in microwave without jar
Cons:
- May be sweet for some
Feed the whole family with the larger jar options available from SKIPPY. You can choose from creamy or creamy roasted honey nut flavors. Each jar is best stored at room temperature for the easiest spreading but can be refrigerated if you prefer.
Peanut Butter and Co. peanut butter
High protein option
With flavors to please every palate, Peanut Butter and Co. really delivers.
Pros:
- Peanuts grown in the USA
- Dessert-like flavors
Cons:
- Some flavors have a lot of sugar
If you want to branch out from your usual plain peanut butter, this company has you covered. Some options taste as nice as a dessert, without the need for any other ingredients. Peanut Butter and Co. has been in business since 1998 and even runs their own 119-acre peanut farm in Arkansas, so they definitely understand what makes good peanut butter!
Happy Belly creamy peanut butter
Just the basics
With a great taste for a price, this peanut butter beats many other options.
Pros:
- Tastes similar to top brands
- Very smooth texture
Cons:
- May separate after sitting a while
If your household uses a lot of peanut butter, this budget-friendly option from Amazon will ease the strain on your wallet. They source their peanuts from the USA and blend them into a super creamy mixture that will delight your taste buds. You can easily elevate the taste of fruits and other dishes with this peanut butter.
Jif Creamy peanut butter
Baking's best friend
This signature brand has one crunchy and two creamy options.
Pros:
- Great for baking recipes
- Rarely separates
Cons:
- Many added ingredients
This is the peanut butter you can reach for and start spreading on your sandwich right away. Jif offers two creamy options, one of which includes Omega-3s, and a crunchy option. If you plan to bake some cookies, this is one of the best peanut kinds of butter to use in your recipe.
Justin's classic peanut butter
No stirring required
This delicious option is made with just two ingredients.
Pros:
- No added salt
- Generous 28-ounce jar
Cons:
- Lower fiber content
This two-ingredient peanut butter offers the creaminess you need for any application. It's made with responsibly sourced peanuts and is certified gluten-free and Kosher. You'll also be surprised to know that it doesn't require stirring, so it's ready to eat when hunger strikes.
Peanut butter for snacks and meals
Why you can trust Real Homes Our expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing products and services so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about how we test.
Which peanut butter will be gracing your fruits and sandwiches? Our favorite option is SKIPPY creamy peanut butter. There's no stirring needed, it's temptingly sweet, and the flavor is always consistent. The large jar options are ideal for big families who really love peanut butter. SKIPPY's honey roasted nut flavor is savory and sweet, making it difficult to pass up.
For those wanting to taste something a bit beyond standard options, we recommend Peanut Butter and Co. peanut butter. They have some tried and true flavor combinations that will be hard to resist, like dark chocolate and peanut butter or peanut butter and honey. Plus, they use only peanuts grown in the USA for their products.